To All Modders

[TheSifodias]

While most people say that you guys create great mods, I am going to be a critic:

1. Simox's Mods (Players,Cp and Guns)
Goods:
+Probably the best new player skins to be made in a pack
+All guns have addons different looks, etc.
+Very Detailed/Accurate Scopes
+Consistent
+Personal Style and Design
+Cp's are quite cool(tank meditruck)
Bads:
-Guns are slightly overdetailed nowdays(M4 Carbine,Dragunov Svd, Scar)

2. kickbutt's Mod Pack
Goods:
+Player Skin and later guns are actually quite good, show time and effort in their detail
+Accepts requests
Bads:
-I know your new but you have to consider updating your first guns. They are really ugly.
-Scopes need improvement.

3. Dimi's Mods
Goods:
+Modern Weapons with arms
+Simplistic yet great
+Nice choice of scopes
Bads:
- You should pay attention to how your stuff looks in the game when you're holding it instead of slab 6

4.Spartan Halo Pack
Goods:
+Great Theme
+Nice Detail
+Consistent Updates
Bad:
- Still testing...

Guys I will be updating this later on as I test more mods. Feel free to add your own criticisms below.

Since I'm not perfect can you please post your mods below so I can have a look at them?

[arti]

uhh k

[ChaosTLW]

What about me? *pomb*

[IrishElf]

Couldn't post your criticisms on the modder's threads? Or even in the mod sub forums?

[TheSifodias]

ChaosTWL: It would be nice if you could post a link to all your mods.
Irishelf: Well isnt Aos talk for this type of stuff? Since I dont see any criticism page on the mod section.

[ChaosTLW]

Well,I dont really have all my mods (most of em were in the Old Forums).
I'm going to post what I have here.

Russian Pack: viewtopic.php?f=71&t=1498&p=17094#p17094
My first good scope: viewtopic.php?f=72&t=2040
M7 Chimera Anti-Personnel/Anti-Materiel Sniper Rifle: viewtopic.php?f=72&t=271
Bushmaster ACR/Magpul Masada: viewtopic.php?f=72&t=377

[IrishElf]

Irishelf: Well isnt Aos talk for this type of stuff? Since I dont see any criticism page on the mod section.

Well...

MODS
Released Mods
Ideas/Discussion
Request/Offer
Modding Help/Resources

[Tai]

If you're going to pretend like your personal opinion warrants an entire thread instead of 3 seperate comments, at least make sure you aren't complaining about something as trivial as a texture pack being "too detailed".

[TheSifodias]

If you're going to pretend like your personal opinion warrants an entire thread instead of 3 seperate comments, at least make sure you aren't complaining about something as trivial as a texture pack being "too detailed".

Actually I hope this thread will take the criticisms of many people.

[Gorman]

1. Simox's Mods (Players,Cp and Guns)
Goods:
+ Good variety
+ Lots of scopes and arms and variants to choose from
Bads:
- Some of the guns look kinda weird to me (SVD)
- Mixed era guns make it hard to make a coherent set
- Didn't tickle my fancy really

2. kickbutt's Mod Pack
Goods:
+ Dragunov looks cool
+ Lots of updates and stuff
+ Very verbose post, good info
Bads:
- Guns look ugly to me
- Player skin looks really ugly
- Sights look ugly and hard to play with

3. Dimi's Mods
Goods:
+ Lots of guns to choose from
+ All the guns look great
+ Post is well made and every gun has a description of what is in the pack, and a well cropped image
+ Lists all the guns at the top of the thread and has full download link too
Bads:
- ...

4.Spartan Halo Pack
Goods:
+ Good quality
+ Looks like the halo ones
+ Well cropped images
Bad:
- Post is kinda weirdly formated
- Individual download links are not there
- ADFLY

[Tai]

Actually I hope this thread will take the criticisms of many people.

Couldn't post your criticisms on the modder's threads? Or even in the mod sub forums?

[Gorman]

Actually I hope this thread will take the criticisms of many people.

Couldn't post your criticisms on the modder's threads? Or even in the mod sub forums?

Cool Tai, reposting what was already said in this thread - IN THIS THREAD.

This is 50% more fun than posting in each individual thread, so I'll stick with this.